Best Used Putters 2026 (UK eBay Deals)

A used putter is one of the smartest purchases in golf. Unlike drivers and irons, putters don't lose distance with age — the feel, alignment, and roll characteristics of a well-made putter remain identical whether it was bought new or ten years used. Scotty Cameron putters in particular are renowned for holding resale value, yet even a used Phantom X or Newport 2 will cost significantly less than new.

We track live UK eBay sold prices for all 59 putter models on ClubScout. The 12 models below represent the best combination of performance, availability, and used market value in 2026 — whether you're looking to spend £80 or £350.

Blade vs Mallet — Which Putter Type Should You Choose?

The most important decision when buying a used putter is the head shape. Blades (like the Scotty Cameron Newport 2 and Special Select) suit golfers with an arcing putting stroke — where the putter naturally swings slightly inside on the backstroke. Mallets (like the TaylorMade Spider GT and Odyssey 2-Ball Ten) suit golfers who putt with a straighter, face-balanced stroke.

If you're unsure which you are, the simple test is this: hold a putter up by the shaft with two fingers and let the head hang freely. If the face points up, it's face-balanced (suited to straighter strokes). If it points away from you at 45°, it has toe hang (suited to arc strokes).

Best Overall: Scotty Cameron Phantom X

The Scotty Cameron Phantom X consistently earns its place at the top of used putter recommendations. The precision-milled aluminium face insert delivers exceptional consistency of roll — more so than the raw stainless face of traditional blade putters. Used examples in excellent condition regularly appear on UK eBay for £250–£350, versus £429 new.

Best Value: Odyssey White Hot OG

The Odyssey White Hot OG revived the legendary White Hot insert that dominated Tour putting in the early 2000s. At £239 new and frequently found used for under £100 in very good condition, it represents extraordinary value. The soft feel from the insert is genuinely difficult to find at this price point.

Best for Beginners: Ping Sigma 2

The Ping Sigma 2 is unique in the used putter market: it comes with an adjustable-length shaft that can be set from 32 to 36 inches without tools. For beginners who haven't yet established a consistent setup and stroke, this adaptability is invaluable. It typically sells used for £80–£120.

What to Check Before Buying a Used Putter

Face condition: The face takes the most wear. Minor ball contact marks are normal. Avoid putters with chips, deep scratches across the face, or damaged inserts.
Neck/hosel: Check that the hosel hasn't been bent. Any deviation from the intended lie angle will significantly affect aim.
Shaft and grip: Grips are cheap to replace (£8–£15 at any pro shop). Don't let a worn grip put you off an otherwise excellent putter.
Length: Most putters are sold at 34 or 35 inches. Your ideal length depends on your height and posture — a fitter can advise, but most players find 34" works for heights of 5'7"–6'1".
Authenticity (for Scotty Cameron): Scotty Cameron putters are frequently counterfeited on eBay. Look for crisp engraving, correct font weights, and a clear headcover with accurate branding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are expensive putters worth buying used?

Yes, particularly for Scotty Cameron. The performance gap between a £350 used Scotty and a £80 budget putter is real — the milling precision and insert materials do affect roll consistency. If you're a feel-sensitive putter, buying used premium is excellent value.

How much should I spend on a used putter?

For most club golfers, £80–£180 covers excellent options (Odyssey, Cleveland, TaylorMade Spider X). For premium mallets and Scotty Cameron blades, budget £200–£350 for used examples in very good condition.

Can I get a putter fitted used?

Partly. Lie angle can sometimes be adjusted by a club fitter. Length can be extended (adding a grip extension) or shortened (cutting the shaft) at low cost. Loft adjustments are more limited on putters. The Ping Sigma 2's adjustable shaft makes it the most fittable used option.

What's the difference between a Scotty Cameron Special Select and Super Select?

The Super Select (2023) uses a new 303 stainless steel formula and updated sole weight system. The Special Select (2021) is slightly softer in feel. Both are excellent — the used price difference rarely justifies paying a premium for the Super Select.

Browse all 59 tracked putter models with live eBay prices on our used putters page.